State Farm® Insurance Agent Amy Tillotson
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
anthony russell
February 11, 2026
"The whole team is extremely polite and wonderful to work with very professional."
"Thank you Anthony for the amazing review! We appreciate you and your business! Thank you for your service to our country!"
daniel113green
February 11, 2026
"Amy Tillotson State Farm Insurance has been my go to insurance company for almost 30 years! Amy’s team goes above and beyond supporting their clients. Today, Amy worked with me to help my daughter get insurance on a new car! Thank you Amy Tillotson State Farm for doing the great job you do!"
"Thank you so much Daniel for this wonderful review! I appreciate your kind words and we appreciate your business! Congratulations to your daughter on her new car! "
Victor Maldonado
January 30, 2026
"Amy Tillotson is an amazing agent — it’s always a great experience working with her. Her passion for what she does truly shows in the way she cares for her clients. We look forward to continuing our partnership and working together in the future."
"Thank you so much for this wonderful review! We love working with you to make our events successful! "
sean lofland
December 13, 2025
"I switched from AAA to State Farm for all my insurance. Home, Auto, Life. Not only have I saved $499.63 a month. I have half the deductible I did before and I have double the coverage. !!! As a bonus her office supports veteran organizations in Alamogordo."
"Thank you Sean for this amazing review! We appreciate you and your business! I am so glad we helped save you money for your home, life and auto insurance!"
Amber Celoria
December 4, 2025
"We love Amy and her team! They go above and beyond in order to ensure that their clients are cared for! Not only are we confidently covered in our home, car, and life insurance, Amy and her team helped us with a travel ID emergency during our recent trip to NYC. The slogan “State Farm is There” is quite accurate. Thank you, Amy!"
"Thank you Amber for this awesome review! We are so happy we can help you with all of your insurance needs. We appreciate you and your business! "
Rona Jones
November 18, 2025
"Great people and services. Always friendly and ready to help you with all your insurance needs."
"Thank you Rona for the great review! We appreciate you!!!"
Alamodoso Magazine
October 21, 2025
"Amy has been our agent for the past four years...wish we had discovered her 20 years ago .. fantastic service"
"Thank you Steve for this amazing review! We appreciate you and your business!"
Timothy Dammit
August 4, 2025
"I recently purchased a new home in Las Cruces New Mexico. I started an insurance policy with a company who assured me they checked numerous policies and only chose the best one. I happen to stop in at my friendly neighborhood local State farm office, and to pay a bill. And inadvertently ask them about home insurance and bundling my vehicles together with it. I was completely blown away after receiving my quote from State farm and the wonderful ladies working there. At first I didn't even believe it was true. They had come up with a policy to bundle my vehicles and home together, that was over $1,000 less than the best policy supposedly from another insurance company. I have given State farm in Alamogordo, Amy tillotson and her crew, all my trust and faith. They are the one company that I have dealt with throughout my whole ordeal that I have absolutely no worry about whatsoever. There's no better feeling than to have insecurities taken away from you and know that you're covered and in good hands LOL I would recommend State farm in Alamogordo Amy tillerson and Valerie to anybody not just in Alamogordo or New Mexico but anywhere in the world. they will have my continued business as long as I'm alive. Thank you very much for making me feel so comfortable with choosing you."
"Tim, thank you for this wonderful review! You are so generous and we appreciate your kind words. We really strive to do our best for our customers and want you to get the best service and coverage for your insurance policies. Love the pictures of your truck!"
Mia Calleros
July 24, 2025
"Amy, Valerie and team are amazing. They are responsive, helpful and funny!"
"Thank you Mia for this great review! We appreciate you!"
Samuel Hatcher
July 16, 2025
"Outstanding customer service and unmatched professionalism!
Amy and her team go above and beyond to make sure every detail is handled with care. Their excellence-driven approach and genuine focus on people make this the perfect place for all your insurance needs. I highly recommend Amy and her staff! You won’t be disappointed!"
"Thank you so much for this wonderful review and affirmation that we really try our best to bring great customer service. We appreciate you and your review! Thank you!"
Steven Wiehn
June 12, 2025
"Very professional and courteous staff, any questions comments or concerns I might have are answered that day the only regret that I have is that I cannot give them more stars:-)"
"Thank you so much Steve for this wonderful review! You are so kind, and we appreciate you!"
Augustine Candelaria
June 12, 2025
"Great service and the best rate in Alamogordo for me. Amy’s team is great! If you need assistance ask for Valerie!! She had answers to all of my questions and if she didn’t know she would find the answer and actually call back! Because of her, filing a claim has been exceptionally easy."
"Thank you so much for the kind review! I’m so happy that we have been able to help you with your insurance and that Valerie has been so helpful. She is a great asset to our team!"
Flip Masters “Flip Masters” Productions
April 23, 2025
"Very lovely people! If you need an amazing insurance agent, Amy and her team is the place to go. Great rates and overall lovely people. 👍"
"Thank you Phillip for this amazing review! We appreciate you and your business! "
barry hurd
March 21, 2025
"Staff is always very polite and have taken care of anything I have ever asked them to do for me.
Excellent customer service."
"Thank you Mr. Hurd for the wonderful review! We appreciate you and your service and are happy you continue to receive excellent service. Thank you for your business!"
Liz Brown
March 7, 2025
"Friendly, fast and efficient. I always enjoy stopping in to pay and say hello to the ladies."
"Thank you Liz for the great review! We appreciate you and your business!"
C.T.
February 13, 2025
"They are very nice folks."
"Thank you so much for this awesome review! We appreciate you!"
Jose Suarez
January 17, 2025
"Amy, Merna and her team are wonderful and super supportive, transparent and made my post accident experience seamless. I recommend reaching out."
"Thank you for the awesome review! We appreciate you and your business and strive to provide great service. Thank you again!"
Adriana Gonzales
December 19, 2024
"Myrna Killebrew is wonderful, she always help us with the things that we need. We ask about our insurance and she immediately responds to us!"
"Thank you so much for this amazing review of Myrna and our office. She is a very valuable team member and always ready to help others. We are so glad you have had great service! Thank you for your business! We appreciate you!"
THERESA Snyder
November 27, 2024
"Great team easy to work with top shelf customer service"
"Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We appreciate you and your business!"
Stacy Brabson
November 8, 2024
"Amy and her team are always kind and willing to help. It is always a pleasure to work with them!"
"Thank you so much Stacy for the awesome review! We appreciate you!"
kimberly kimberly
November 7, 2024
"Amy Tillotson, and her staff are knowledgeable, professional, and will go the extra mile to make sure they take care of your needs. I am so thankful that we have had our insurance with her office for the last three years. I can feel how much they care about their clients when I interact with her office, either in office or over the phone. If you are looking for an insurance provider that will care about you as a person and offers exceptional insurance, please do you yourself a favor and choose Amy Tillotson Statefarm."
"Thank you so much Kimberly for this wonderful review! We appreciate you, your business and for being so gracious! You are truly a blessing!"
James Flores (Zeronox)
November 6, 2024
"I have the privilege of having many interactions with the wonderful women who work here every week. They always welcome with a smile and do their best to always remember everyone’s names. They go above and beyond for their customers! Give them a chance anytime, they do that best to find you the best rates!"
"Thank you James for this amazing review of our office! We appreciate you! "
Cathy Carter
October 23, 2024
"Myrna was quick to respond to my call. She went above and beyond to meet my needs and continues to provide excellent customer service."
"Thank you Cathy for this wonderful review! I am so glad that Myrna was able to help you and take care of you quickly and efficiently. We appreciate you and your business!"
Kaleb Wilson
October 14, 2024
"Amy Tillotson is an incredible agent. She provides great customer service and makes you feel like you are taken care of properly. I recommend her office to anyone needing great rates and help guiding on what is needed for you. Amy Tillotson is a trustworthy agent who values integrity and family. Thank you Amy Tillotson."
"Thank you Kaleb for this awesome review! We appreciate you and your business and truly work at providing the highest quality of service we can to everyone! "
Haley Vann
October 4, 2024
"Very helpful, professional and puts the customers first."
"Thank you Haley for the awesome review! We appreciate you and your business!"